Senate Votes for Cuts in Medicare Home Health Payments
What’s the point of extending insurance to more people if you are cutting the benefits of medicare recipients? That just leaves the medicare patients in the same boat as those who previously didn’t have insurance….unable to afford needed medical care.
I’ve said all along that while I support the idea of health care reform, I would withhold judgment on the specific plan until I saw the plan. I’m not sure I can support a plan that makes it harder for medicare beneficiaries to get home health care.
(Thanks for the link Sky.)
WASHINGTON — Snowflakes swirled around the Capitol on Saturday, whipped by wintry winds, but on the Senate floor inside, a heated debate raged as Democrats and Republicans traded jabs over legislation to achieve President Obama’s goal of near-universal health insurance coverage.
By a vote of 53 to 41, the Senate on Saturday rejected a Republican effort to block cutbacks in payments to home health agencies that provide nursing care and therapy to homebound Medicare beneficiaries.
Republicans voted against the cuts, saying they would hurt some of the nation’s most vulnerable citizens. Most Democrats supported the cutbacks, saying they would eliminate waste and inefficiency in home care.
The Democrats’ health care bill would reduce projected Medicare spending on home care by $43 billion, or 13 percent, over the next 10 years. The savings would help offset the cost of subsidizing coverage for the uninsured.
[SNIP]
“We are reducing overpayments,” Mr. Baucus said. “We are rooting out fraud. We are getting the waste out. The savings go back in Medicare and extend the solvency of the trust fund.”





December 7th, 2009 at 2:26 pm
Rethuglicans actually caring about someone other than themselves? Something sounds fishy here and I just ain’t buying it. These people would throw their own family under the bus if it meant protecting big business and their money.
Sage Reply:
December 7th, 2009 at 2:59 pm
I would like to see the breakdown on this…..how are these cuts really going to effect those who use home health care?
AliSilver Reply:
December 7th, 2009 at 3:42 pm
@obotinchief, Obot, Don’t be fooled by fancy rhetoric !This is not about caring at all…. It’s about REPS knowing their only chance to win anything in ’10 is if SOMEONE is in their corner… someone LIKE seniors who saw the gop TRYING to save their home health care. .
Sage… I wonder too. My mom is on a LOT of homehealth care through medicare…….. I wonder if they will get like a statement informing them of the changes.
Sage Reply:
December 7th, 2009 at 4:06 pm
By-the-way, thanks for the link…and no, I don’t mind at all.
timesr Reply:
December 7th, 2009 at 11:19 pm
@obotinchief, “Rethuglicans actually caring about someone other than themselves? Something sounds fishy here and I just ain’t buying it.”
Having just been through all this with my dad who died in August and my mother who died in January 2008, I’m not buying it either.
Home health care through Medicare was not available for either. Hospice services were available through Medicare, but that is not the same as home health care.
For my mother, we had to hire 24 hour care. My dad was in a board and care home – the cost was pretty much the same – around $6,000 a month either way.
Had my parents not had assets, or if they had planned, they would have qualified for MediCal. That’s pretty complex – there are lawyers who specialize in MediCal planning, but its a state, not a federal program though I think the state does get some federal funds.
December 7th, 2009 at 3:02 pm
Isn’t that A$$ backwards? Find the fraud then cut back when savings are realized. Cutting back first is going to do nothing to eliminate fraud. It will reduce the quality of care and wages of those that care for those being cared for at home. Overall, home care is cheaper already.
Sage Reply:
December 7th, 2009 at 3:33 pm
Exactly. Home care keeps my 92 year old aunt out of a nursing home. It also gives her daughter a much needed break from care as well.
December 7th, 2009 at 3:47 pm
Oops I lied. Mom’s not on home health care. She has lots of equipment and machines and meds brought to her home and maintanenced there but she does not have a provider who comes in daily.