Dad’s Death Panel – guest author Wizcon
Thanks to Wizcon.
Dad’s Death Panel
Thirty years ago, Mom and Dad came to my brothers and I with a medical directives following an extensive physical at Stanford as a requirement for his new position in the middle east. It is several pages of very small print and very detailed. They did it at the insistence of Dad’s employer and after talking to their Dr. Our conversations with him about that document have always centered around quality of life and what “Hope” means in medical situations. Along with that document was a power of attorney for their personal and financial affairs. When Mom died in Saudi Arabia, protests against her wishes were easily dispersed with that document.
When he was first diagnosed with Alzheimers in 2002, he was wintering in Yuma, AZ. Since his retirement in 1985, he had been living and traveling fulltime in his airstream. His first response to the news was to say he was going to walk out into the desert. Then he went on to 5 more yrs of traveling with his friends.
Dad is now 90 yrs old. He looks at his feet in bafflement when they do not respond to his brains command to move. He winces in pain during an ultrasound but says he is not in pain. Pain isn’t a definition he can communicate anymore. He has no understanding of the word. But he feels it. Last month the battery in his pacemaker needed replacement. They were able to do it under light anesthesia and in the office. This month a gall stone was blocking a duct in his pancreas. They were able to remove that in day surgery under light anesthesia and by going down his throat. But the conversations with all the Doctors in regard to the gall bladder full of stones went as follows: “He is not a candidate for surgery because of his age. It will kill him” Or “what quality of life he has will rapidly decline if he survives”. It all seems very clinical at the time. After all, they are talking about my Dad. Would risky surgery do him any benefit at all? Would it improve or destroy the quality of his life tucked safely away in an assisted living home? To my brother and I, insisting on those surgeries ,with those odds, were cruel and inhumane.
It’s the same conversation we had about the lesions in his lungs, a souvenir from his service in WW2. He still had cognition and able to input into his care when they told him it looked like they had turned cancerous. He said, don’t treat it. Don’t biopsy it. They told him he was not a good candidate for that surgery as well. He wanted to go on in his own terms.
Even though the POA’s have been activated, my brother has been outstanding in keeping everyone informed of what is going on. He includes Dad and me in all decisions. Decisions are made based on his comfort because that is what he can understand and feel. It is now up to our reliance on his directives and his words to guide us in decision making.
It is getting so Dad cannot talk on the phone anymore. There is no face to connect to and no ability to follow more than a sentence at a time. Questions baffle and frustrate him. He just plain doesn’t know what is going on in front of him. He doesn’t know his past. He watches the activities of those around him and often falls sideways in his chair. He is disappearing into silence. He cannot speak for himself.
I would hate to think where we would be without those directives. We know we are honoring his wishes. Whether he knows it or not, he is going to have the closest thing possible to the kind of death he wanted.
In his time and on his terms.





November 23rd, 2009 at 8:00 pm
Oh WIZ !
November 23rd, 2009 at 8:43 pm
I wrote this because the phrase “death panels” keep coming up as a scare tactic. I cannot understand peoples resistance to consulting with a Dr about end of life decisions. It is with Dr’s guidance and information that we make these decisions when the loved one cannot communicate or understand what is going on. In the absence of loved ones to look after you, a guardian is usually appointed. I was guardian to a protectively placed man, an old schizophrenic, with whom I had a friendship. I was also guardian to my grandmother. She was able to tell me what she did NOT want before going silent.
It would bother me to no end if my children were not able to input into my care because I failed to write down my wishes. Conversley I would not have been able to make decisions for my young adult daughter when she was gravely ill had I not convinced her to draw up a directive and POA. When your children turn 18, you are no longer privy to their medical information.
timesr Reply:
November 23rd, 2009 at 11:52 pm
@Wizcon,
My thoughts and prayers are with you and your family.
My mother died in 2008 without a directive and had dementia for the last year of her life. It was difficult not knowing what she wanted after she had a stroke that killed her within a few days. I would not wish that on anyone.
My dad died in August and had a directive, it was still hard, but knowing what he wanted gave us direction.
November 23rd, 2009 at 9:53 pm
Hi there.
This has to be so hard for you and your family. My parents have written out directives as well. I believe I hold the medical power of attorney. It’s a painful topic of discussion but it’s a necessary discussion. Thanks for sharing.
November 24th, 2009 at 6:37 am
Death used to be so uncomplicated it seems like an eternity ago.
When my mother died no one talked about life support systems; the family pooled together and took care of her. She died after a long illness with cancer in the l950s. Also in the 1950s my grandmother died at home with the family taking care of her in the day time and at night nuns of Mercy would come to the house and take care of her. Nolife support systems. No ACLSFs, Nursing Homes or Hospices … Death was a natural process (which it still is but which we have made more complicated by life support systems, lack of Right to Die with Dignity directives, big pharma money making machines, doctors who want to squeeze the last penny and last dime out of their dying patients …it is all too sad that our natural dying has been so extricated out of our lives. I think that if a Right to Die with Dignity Directive could say LET ME DIE A NATURAL DEATH, people might not be so afraid and fearful to sign one). May LOVE be the central part in your father’s natural process.
AliSilver Reply:
November 24th, 2009 at 8:31 am
@skyagunsta, ”May LOVE be the central part in your father’s natural process” SKYA,,, I love this statement !!! Kudos.
May I add ” peace” as well to everyone involved, Wiz !
November 24th, 2009 at 8:57 am
Thank you all. His mother spent the last 10 yrs of her life in dementia and she lived to be 102. My aunt had been her POA but died rather quickly from cancer. That left Grandma in limbo. The remaining children signed a document stating they wanted me to oversee her care.She signed herself out of the home she was in and in to the one near me. So we did not have to go through the courts. She was a vital part of our life. My daughters were witness to the process. The home she was in allowed and encouraged family to do personal care on her such as bathing
I considered caring for my Dad, but he said he did not want that, mostly because he is so huge. He was also worried he would hurt me in his confusion later on. I am also self employed. Earning a living would be next to impossible.
My directive says “comfort only” in the event of a terminal situation. Having helped care for my brother and ex through terminal cancer in the last few yrs helps with that decision. But who knows how you feel about all that when you are in that situation. You make your decisions while you can, then turn it over to those who you trust and hopefully love you and respect your wishes.